Home2023-08-21T14:40:19+00:00

21 Reasons to Reject ‘Sola Scriptura,’ by Joel Peters.

In my last article Debating Protestants, I discussed how and why I used to debate Protestants on a nearly-daily basis with open-Bible verse-wars when I was in my early 20s.  After learning that these verse-wars rarely make converts, I learned the best way to disprove Protestantism is by simply overturning their completely non-Biblical notion of Sola Scriptura. The little pamphlet in the above picture is called Scripture Alone? 21 Reasons to Reject Sola Scriptura by Mr. Joel Peters.  It is the very best book I have ever seen to aid Catholics in immediately sidelining the intellectual errors of Protestantism.  But it's very difficult to find on the internet now. Thus, I copied it below (word-for-word) from past websites that apparently crossposted it into the public forum. Perhaps the author took it down to sell his new book, which I’m sure is [...]

By |April 16th, 2026|

Debating Protestants.

Happy Easter, Christ is Risen!  Christ is Truly Risen! Χριστὸς ἀνέστη! Ἀληθῶς ἀνέστη! As you probably know, I currently spend more time attacking the heresy of Modernism than Protestantism. Why? Because the former is a cancer that any traditionalist Catholic will admit is more hidden, ubiquitous and destructive than the latter.  So, I will keep defending the original Apostolic Faith against modernists who control the buildings. But I first cut my teeth on defending the True Faith by doing open-Bible debates with Protestants in my world travels starting 30 years ago.  Before getting to how I did this, let’s define terms. Even National Geographic or a secular Social Studies book will admit there’s only three main branches of Christianity: Catholicism, Orthodoxy and Protestantism. Yet, today I meet many evangelicals, Pentecostals, “emergent church” folks and non-denominationalists who all dislike the term [...]

By |April 14th, 2026|

More Conversions (and Departures.)

p/c University of Notre Dame. Doubtless by this point you have seen the news of massive amounts of conversions of non-Catholic young adults coming into American Catholic parishes.  This news has been covered by both religious outlets as well as secular ones. Many of these conversions are in unlikely places, like New York City.  NCR/EWTN recently reported on a Dominican parish in lower Manhattan serving NYU: "88 people received the sacraments of baptism or confirmation at the Easter vigil this year."  Part of this was due to current events:  "Many of those coming into the Church, he said, have told him that conservative Christian influencer Charlie Kirk’s murder had a huge effect on them." The conversions are good news.  But we need to zoom out a little bit to see what is happening in the big picture.  People are going [...]

By |April 9th, 2026|

St. John and the Synoptics in the Triduum.

Every Triduum, thousands of Catholics (including me) ask the following question: Why do the Synoptic Gospels (Saints Matthew, Mark and Luke) place the Passover on one date and it seems that St. John places it on a different date? The answer I gave for several years was the calendar of the Pharisees was different from that of the Essenes. However, I discovered that that answer leads to more problems than solutions. Before we look at the real answer, I want to remind you of a definition known to most traditional Catholics.  Archaeologism is a modernist fad found in Church history and liturgical studies, often used by charismatics. One aspect of this error is to foist Medieval Jewish practices upon the Catholic sacraments. Of course, there is nothing wrong with the fact that God Himself used Old Testament rituals as the [...]

By |April 2nd, 2026|

Trads Behind the Iron Curtain.

The only novel I have read since ordination was Michael O'Brien's Island of the World.  It's a gripping and grinding historical-fiction account about a man named Josip who grows up in Croatia in the 1940s.  His family and community is then destroyed by Tito's communism.  Josip is sent to a gulag called Goli Otok in real life.  There, he is tortured and loses his faith.  After escaping, he wanders Italy and finally ends up a janitor in NYC.  Does he regain his faith?  You'll have to read the book.  It was so good I read it twice since ordination. Since reading Island of the World, I have had a healthy fascination with Croatia.  The book captures the fact that Croatia is the crossroads between a Catholicism that can be described as both Western and Eastern (although it is certainly more [...]

By |March 31st, 2026|

Marital Chastity.

Warning: This is an article for adults, not children. The topic today is this:  What is permitted behavior in the bedroom between Catholic spouses?  From the start, I have to give this disclaimer: I despise writing about this topic, especially since I endanger my own soul in bringing potentially-immodest writings to the internet (as if the internet does not already have enough.) However, I have discovered that the question of exotic behavior in the bedroom is unfortunately on the minds of countless Catholic couples across the globe.  Similarly, I have unfortunately found that 98% of priest-confessors out there are misleading the Catholic laity on this topic.  By what authority can I claim they are "misleading" them while I seem to know better?  Because we actually have the answers from the Church Fathers and the Doctors of the Catholic Church. Some [...]

By |March 24th, 2026|
Go to Top