Outside the oldest cathedral, a mysterious man solved an enigma on Fatima I had pondered for years.
In 2017, I was on loan to the Diocese of St. Augustine, Florida. I was stationed at the Cathedral Basilica of the Immaculate Conception in Jacksonville where I did exclusively the Traditional Latin Mass. I was also involved in campus ministry at University of Northern Florida. Before going to campus, I often prayed and counseled at a Jacksonville abortion center. On Sundays, I also taught classes to families who were very eager to learn. I have never met families so thrilled to learn the traditional faith (read: the true faith) as them.
So, even though most my time was spent in Jacksonville, I occasionally went to the town of St. Augustine, which was the official heart of the diocese, despite being smaller than Jacksonville (which contains most the parishes.)
As many of you know, St. Augustine is where one of the first Masses took place on US soil, specifically on Our Lady’s birthday in the year 1565. The reason I say the Mass there in 1565 was only one of the first Masses on US soil is because there are other records going back to Mass being offered in South Carolina in 1526 and even earlier in Florida in 1513 by one of the priestly crew members of Ponce de León’s ship.
Also, the Cathedral there in St. Augustine, Florida is the oldest Catholic active parish still running from her 16th century edifice, notwithstanding having been burnt down a whopping four times (in 1586, 1599, 1702 and 1887. )
In any case, I mentioned on a podcast several years ago how I met a homeless man outside the Cathedral in St. Augustine. I asked him why so many of the hierarchy was losing the faith. To my utter shock, he did not demure. Rather, he gave a perfectly precise—and rhyming answer—that prophetically explained Fatima!
He was a white, rapping homeless man. So, I then asked him a harder question. I asked him why, if Fatima were true, would Mary have mentioned immodesty to Sister Lucy instead of abortion for the newly-arrived 20th century when both were uncommon. Certainly abortion is so much worse than immodesty if her prophesy were perfect? And perfect is obviously the only way Our Lady would deliver this prophesy. (So, in asking the homeless man that question, I was not doubting the veracity of Fatima, but just testing his wisdom on a tough question I had been intensely pondering at the time.)
Surprisingly, one of the listeners to my podcast was equally haunted by my mention of that prophetic homeless man, even this many years later. Today, he wrote me an email saying he has asked many Floridians online if they have ever countered such a poetic prophet outside the Cathedral of St. Augustine. No one has ever heard of him. In fact, one of his friends doubted my story to the point of suggesting it “did not literally and factually occur.”
A listener to my podcast just wrote me this email:
Good morning Father,
I have found the story of your encounter with an itinerant traditional Catholic rapper outside the cathedral of Saint Augustine, Florida fascinating ever since I first read it a couple of years ago. I am active online with Catholic friends & acquaintances across the country, so every time I meet a Floridian I ask them if they have ever heard any trace of this amazing figure. Unfortunately, maybe because it’s been so long since the event occurred, I’ve never gotten a lead. If I am ever in Florida, on-the-ground gumshoe work will be a fun quest of mine.
However, it was exactly in one of these conversations that an older (relative to my mid-20s) man with generational experience in the traditional movement insisted that you were joking, satirizing, or that this event otherwise did not literally & factually occur. So Father, I would like to ask, have I been daft this whole time?
In Jesus through Mary,
Robby
I replied (not knowing I would decide to publish this on my site until hitting send, and changing his name):
Dear Robby,
That’s funny you remember that man!
Yes, I remember him like it was yesterday. It happened in front of the Cathedral of St. Augustine. I asked him numerous mysteries to the current Church crisis and that homeless white man gave rapping and rhyming answers in a way that made me think he was like an Old Testament prophet.
You probably remember the one I mentioned on the podcast that I asked him why, if Fatima was real, did Mary predict immodesty instead of abortion? He gave the most incredible rhyme about how abortion is based on contraception, and contraception on p*rn, and p*rn came from immodesty. He absolutely blew me away.
So, if you are asking other Floridians about him, you have to remember most young Catholics like to talk a lot about the poor without spending time with them… and of the few that do, how many are going to really trust the answer of a homeless man? And of that small population, how many are going to ask a homeless man about why Rome has lost the faith like I did?
So, you’re talking about a very very tiny population of active Floridian Catholics that would never check the boxes of everything I described above… and, the life on the streets has an extremely quick expiration date, so I bet my homeless hero is probably deceased by now… so say a prayer for him this month of Holy Souls.
Fr. David
Following that email, here’s a few things to highlight about that street-experience:
- That homeless prophet had the traditional faith in his heart even though he probably had no access to the Traditional Latin Mass. Even if he is currently reposing with the Lord, he (and especially his traditional Catholic faith) somewhat represents that very Cathedral where I met him: Destroyed four times and yet still active. Yes, that Cathedral is still standing (albeit with Novus Ordo liturgy and doctrine inside) but that homeless man who worshipped there presumably kept the true traditional faith until his final breath despite all the challenges of life on the streets and rejection at local parishes.
- Please realize the connection between immodesty and abortion, as he did. Our Lady of Fatima said in 1917, “Certain fashions will be introduced that will offend Our Lord very much.” A small booklet can be found about that very line here. Yet, most women do not realize their clothing will lead men to sin. (Yes, yes, I know the men are responsible too for what they go and do alone at home after seeing immodestly dressed women, but literally everyone knows that, including non-Christians.) Yet, what most Catholics refuse to admit today is that women are going to answer for such sins they provoked, too. And Mary didn’t just mean, say, the bikini as the farthest stretch of damnable clothing for women that would soon come on the scene to “offend Our Lord very much.” Rather, Mary probably even meant pants on women, as pants were only for men when she said that in 1917. (See Deuteronomy 22:5’s condemnation of women wearing men’s clothing to understand how serious cross-dressing is.) So… I think at this point in my article, you can either call me “an extremist” or just do a little Paschal’s wager by asking yourself, “What if—just what if Fr. David is correct?” Or, even better, “What exactly did Our Lady mean back in 1917 by a doomed future’s certain fashions?” Did she mean only yoga pants? Or something much more common that never even existed on women before the 20th century? Keep in mind as you answer that heaven does not grade on a curve, but rather on holiness, for God said You shall be holy, for I am holy.—1 Peter 1:16.
- If any of you have encountered that mysterious homeless prophet anywhere on the streets of Florida (or anywhere else) please send him my best and please send me an email that you found him.
